Check out Musco Real. Its very much a more traditional after shave. I shave with a straight razor and it works great for me.

Voting... Voted Vote as Best Answer

Check out Nivea products. The scent isn't strong and the products are really good for your skin.

Voting... Voted Vote as Best Answer
1 person voted for this

Im a sucker for Baxter of California and Grooming Lounge's Best For Last after Shave Both are really clean and simple, nothing to strong and they do a great job of closing up the skin after a nice hot shave.

Voting... Voted Vote as Best Answer

I know you said you wanted a classic scent but you should try Abercrombie Fierce, it smells amazing and it has feromones in it so the ladies like it too.

Voting... Voted Vote as Best Answer

I love Fire Fighter from Origins. It soothes really well and doesn't have a lingering scent.

Voting... Voted Vote as Best Answer

I've been a big fan of The Gentleman's Refinery afrer shave balm
the product is extremely moisturizing and is quickly absorbed. All of the products from "The Gentlemans Refinery" are of the highest quality and all natural ingredients.
The only down side is that it is a little pricey.

Voting... Voted Vote as Best Answer

I use Gillette Fusion Gel. It makes my skin feel really soft and not greasy or heavy.

Voting... Voted Vote as Best Answer

Answer This Question

Please provide links to products you recommend or your answer will not be accepted.
Use this code to make a link.
"Product Name":http://www.example.com → Product Name

Related Questions

What is the best at-home teeth whitening product?

How do you spit like a baseball player?

What kind of tattoos won't make me look like a tool?

How do I stop upper-lip sweating?

What is the best way to stop biting my nails?

What is the cheapest and most effective way to stop snoring?