Finding the right face wash can be a challenge, and finding a toxin-free cleanser can be even tougher. Pangea Organics Facial Cleanser ($25) is a good choice, with a vegetable glycerin base in lieu of animal fat, Egyptian calendula to soothe your skin, and blood orange to degrease. Hand-crafted, it's the most natural face wash we've found.
Save your face post-shave with the Peter Thomas Roth Conditioning Multi Tasking After Shave Tonic ($20). The product's long name is preceded by a long list of ingredients — pro vitamin B5, allantoin, glycerin, menthol, witch hazel, mandarin orange, and lemon peel — that soothe shaving irritation and moisturize at the same time.